Weekly Progress
Week 1 Progress
4/4/17
This week in lab we formed teams to tackle the challenge of designing a sky way. Between the four members of the group, we proposed two bridge locations and one sky way location. The picture below depicts a rough model of the path that the bridge would follow spanning over Market Street. The next proposed location spans over 33rd Street on Lancaster Walk. The final location, the sky way, connects Gerri C. Lebow Hall to Pearlstein Business Learning Center. Before week two of lab, we plan to survey each area for pedestrian and car traffic along with surveying students to find which proposed bridge would be the most beneficial. Lastly, in lab, we set up this blog in which we will make weekly posts about our project.
| Figure 1: Rough idea for the track of a bridge spanning market street |
Today we created a survey to poll students on our proposed bridge locations. We will be sending this out to as many students as we can. We will analyze the results to find out what location would benefit students the most. We also sat outside the DAC and monitored traffic at the intersection of 33rd street and Market Street. We will use this data to see if a bridge would benefit both car and pedestrian traffic.
Link to survey: https://surveynuts.com/surveys/take?id=132514&c=1882758929PHJL
As we surveyed pedestrian and automobile traffic, a go-pro was set up to record a time-lapse of the intersection. Each of the two videos are 30 minutes long, but condensed in time to create the time-lapse. While surveying, we noted average times of pedestrians crossing both streets, average wait time for pedestrians, and how many times automobiles had to stop when they had the right of way to turn.
Figure 2: Time-lapse of Market Street traffic
Figure 3: Time-lapse 2 of Market Street traffic
Week 2 Progress
4/11/17
Today in lab we did research on which permits are necessary for a bridge spanning over a city street. We also researched materials to use and looked at other pedestrian bridge designs. We started sketching preliminary design for our three locations. This was so we can get a jump start on our actual design once we have enough research to decide on a site. The sketch below depicts the cross section of Market Street and 33rd Street in the heart of Drexel's Campus. Stairs are drawn parallel to to 33rd Street and ramps for wheelchair accessibility parallel to Market Street. The length of the intersections are labeled and our design for the spanning bridge over top will either be a square or a circle. Measurements on all sections of the bridge are yet to come if this is the location picked.
Figure 4: Rough sketch of Market Street skyway
4/16/17
Today we reviewed our updated survey results as well as monitored the Lancaster walk location. The survey showed a very small number of people walk between Lebow and the Pearlstein building so, a bridge there would not benefit a large population of Drexel students and faculty. Ruling out that location, we are left with two possible skyway locations.
Looking below at the screenshot of our data in Excel we can conclude the average time it takes to cross over Market Street and 33rd Street is about 40 seconds. During the surveying we excluded people on bikes, scooters, and skateboards. More information on how we surveyed can be found in the tutorials section of the blog. Not depicted below, but very important in our surveying was the number of pedestrians who were almost hit by automobiles. It was not overlooked to notice automobiles while surveying. While they make right turns off of Market or off of 33rd Street, these cars have the right of way, but so often have to wait for pedestrians to cross. It was noted over 15 times where a car had to abruptly stop in order to not hit a pedestrian in the cross walk. So, from these two pieces of data, this intersection could easily be enhanced by a Skyway and that is why, as of now, it is our number one location of interest.
Table 1: Spreadsheet of recorded wait times at Market Street
used to find the average wait per person.
Week 3 Progress
4/18/17
In the program, Fusion 360, a 3-Dimensional model was crafted to replicate the stair design that would be incorporated into our bridge design over Market Street. In order to save space on the ground, we have the stairs "come back" on themselves with a platform at the back. Each of the 26 steps are 6.67 inches in height and 10.15 inches in depth. This incline is fit for the state of Pennsylvania. The entire staircase is 16 feet long and 15 feet in height.
Figure 5: CAD design of a staircase for the skyway
4/24/17
Out of lab this week we monitored foot and car traffic at the Lancaster walk location. We calculated the average wait time for a pedestrian, which was only 2.25 seconds. This is much less than the average wait we found for Market Street, 39.88 seconds. After collecting all of our data we had enough information to form a decision matrix. In this we rate each location from 1 to 3 in many different categories. The location with the highest total is the one we have agreed on as the best fit for a skyway. That location is the Market Street location.
Out of lab this week we monitored foot and car traffic at the Lancaster walk location. We calculated the average wait time for a pedestrian, which was only 2.25 seconds. This is much less than the average wait we found for Market Street, 39.88 seconds. After collecting all of our data we had enough information to form a decision matrix. In this we rate each location from 1 to 3 in many different categories. The location with the highest total is the one we have agreed on as the best fit for a skyway. That location is the Market Street location.
Market street location
|
Lancaster walk location
|
Lebow/Pearlstine location
|
|
Feasible location
|
3
|
2
|
1
|
Most foot traffic
|
3
|
2
|
1
|
Most car traffic
|
3
|
2
|
No car traffic
|
Longest wait for pedestrians
|
3
|
2
|
No wait
|
Estimated price
|
2
|
3
|
1
|
Least interference during construction
|
1
|
2
|
3
|
Top rated location by polled students
|
3
|
2
|
1
|
Total
|
18
|
15
|
7
|
Table 2: Decision matrix
Week 4 Progress
4/28/17
This week out of lab we made a rough CAD design of or bridge. It is not to scale. We just wanted to use it as a reference for later. This cleared up confusion between group members on what the design will actually look like. Also this week we tried to get a design software to help calculate the load on the columns for the bridge. This attempt was unsuccessful however, as the software was too expensive, and the trial versions did not have sufficient detail. We will have to do more in depth research in order to calculate the estimated load.
Week 4 Progress
4/25/17
The final design of the stairs was finished on Fusion 360 with proper dimensions and specifications by the city of Philadelphia. There are 13 steps, a platform, and 13 more steps coming back on the design. The angle of incline is 33.29 degrees above zero. Each step inclines 6.67 inches, is 10.15 inches in depth, and 60 inches across. The railings are 56 inches in height which match the specifications of the city. The platform halfway up the stair case is a rectangle of 70 by 115 inches. The height of the ramp is 168 inches which is exactly 14 feet. There is one supporting column in the middle of the platform that will distribute the weight of the stair case. This staircase will run parallel to 33rd Street.
Figure 6: 3D model of staircase to bridge
4/28/17
This week out of lab we made a rough CAD design of or bridge. It is not to scale. We just wanted to use it as a reference for later. This cleared up confusion between group members on what the design will actually look like. Also this week we tried to get a design software to help calculate the load on the columns for the bridge. This attempt was unsuccessful however, as the software was too expensive, and the trial versions did not have sufficient detail. We will have to do more in depth research in order to calculate the estimated load.
Figure 7: Rough 3D design of Bridge
Week 5 progress
5/2/17
A working drawing for the enclosed bridge sections was completed. It is designed as a modular design, in 10 foot sections. Each section is a total of 10 feet long with a 1 foot divider between each section. Below is a section of the current budget that is being formed. This section contains all the construction permits required for the bridge. The permit number, description, cost, and supplier are all listed in the chart.
A working drawing for the enclosed bridge sections was completed. It is designed as a modular design, in 10 foot sections. Each section is a total of 10 feet long with a 1 foot divider between each section. Below is a section of the current budget that is being formed. This section contains all the construction permits required for the bridge. The permit number, description, cost, and supplier are all listed in the chart.
![]() |
| Table 3: Budget breakdown for Construction Permits |
5/6/17
The final design of the ramp which will run parallel to Market Street was completed outside of lab on Fusion 360 following the specifications of the city of Philadelphia. The ramp is 84.5 feet long and 5 feet wide on an angle of 4.7 degrees which then reaches a platform and comes back on itself another 84.5 feet until it reaches its maximum height of 14 feet. The platform is 7 feet long and 10 feet wide that includes a semi-circle with radius 5 feet on the back. A column is centered under the platform for support that has radius of 2 feet. The hand rails are 56 inches tall and meet the required height for the city of Philadelphia.
Figure 8: 3D model of ramp to bridge
Week 6 Progress
5/9/17
This wee in Lab we developed the design for a 10 foot section of the bridge span. These will be connected to create the full bridge span. It has a 6 foot wide walkway and 8 feet between the floor and the ceiling.
Figure 9: 3D model of bridge section
5/12/17
Today we made an assembly of our design. it has a ramp and stairs at each corner. the ramps run parallel to Market Street. The stairs run parallel to 33rd Street. There are 8 10 foot sections connected when spanning Market Street and 6 when spanning 33rd Street.
Figure 10: 3D assembly of bridge
Week 7 Progress
5/16/17
This week in lab we worked on designing the platform that connects each bridge spans. Our original design was not feasible and we had to redo it. We decided to change it to a platform that leads to to each of the 10 foot walkways with railings before meeting the tunnel spans. It has extra supports underneath to help distribute the weight of the bridge. It also makes the bridge more aesthetically pleasing.
Figure 11: Corner section of bridge
5/20/17
After several attempts to properly assemble the bridge with the correct constraints and after reconstructing many of our original base pieces, the 3D model is complete. The bridge will now be 3D printed, assembled, and presented during our final report to our peers and instructors.
After several attempts to properly assemble the bridge with the correct constraints and after reconstructing many of our original base pieces, the 3D model is complete. The bridge will now be 3D printed, assembled, and presented during our final report to our peers and instructors.
Week 8 Progress
5/23/17
This week in lab there was a standstill with our progress. Our group scaled down our entire 3-D model, uploaded it to the AfiniaStudio software, learned the software, and started to 3-D print of the stairs. When we returned three hours later to pick up the finished product, it was found out that every printer in the Innovation Studio was having technical difficulties. Unfortunately we would not have our model finished in the time we wanted so we had to come together as a group and revise the plan.
Figure 13: 3-D printers out of service
5/28/17
Outside of lab, a couple of group members took a trip to the local Home Depot. This was not originally in the plan of construction, but after all 3-D printers available to us as students failed, we had to improvise. Instead of 3-D printing the entire bridge, we have now decided to print one corner, including a ramp, staircase, and a corner platform. The overpass, the tubular shapes, will be represented by 1-1/4 inch fluorescent tube protector. The only printer available to us at the time is a peer whom has his own printer in the dorm. We don't want nor think it is feasible for him to print out the entirety of our bridge so that is why we are only printing a corner piece and substituting the tube protector in. The bridge's final model will not look as complete as we originally planned it to, but with a corner section finished, other students and faculty will have a very good idea of what the entire bridge would look like spanning over Market and 33rd Street.
Figure 14: PVC pipe to replace part of the 3-D model design
Week 9 Progress
5/30/17
During lab this week the group worked on the power point slides for the final presentation of the skyway project. The group also ran into some difficulty locating a 3-D printer to use, as the peer who was mentioned in the last post could not be reached. This caused the group to look for other ways to construct a model of the bridge. Ultimately the group was able to find another student, who had access to Wesphal 3-D printers.















Comments
Post a Comment